Thursday, October 1, 2009

What struggles are Angel facing in his life?

24 comments:

  1. Angel is at the point in his life where he needs to decide what he wants to do for the rest of it. He does not want to be a parson, this creates struggles for him because his family not accept this. Because of that they are very unsupportive and Angel is unable to get a university education- something the reader can safely assume he wants due to comments about his high level of reading and intelligence. Angel is left to struggle with what to do with his life without his family's support or a university education.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I agree with janice, but besides his family life Angel now has to worry about Tess. He has finally convinced his family that Tess is a good, pure christian, which we all know is not the truth. Now he has lied to his family, and he has married Tess. Once Angel finds out about Tess' dark past he is unable to say that he loves her as he once thought he did. I think it is wrong that he cannot forgive her because he has done almost the same thing as her, only worse. Angel is now struggling with his feelings for Tess and what he should do with the situation.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I agree with Janice and Margo that Angel was dealing with family problems and now has to deal with his relationship with Tess. Angel also has internal struggles because he cannot really decide what he wants to do with his life. Angel has problems with his family because they wanted him to be a parson, and get a university education, but Angel refused. This made his parents upset because they valued their respect in society and they believed that respect in society is gained by working in high positions such as in the church. Angel then chooses to work on the dairy because he enjoys farming and he want to own his own farm, but his parents do not like this. Another problem Angel has is his relationship with Tess. Angel loves Tess, but she does not agree to marry him because she feels she is unworthy. Finally they get married and they both confess their sins, but Angel does not forgive Tess even though Tess forgives him. This causes a problem because in one moment Angel completely hates Tess even though he had admired her before she had told him about her relationship with Alec. I think that Angel is uncertain about what he wants in his life because he loves Tess, but not enough to forgive her. He also is not sure what he wants to be in his life because he refused to be a parson, and then did various jobs until he finally began to work at the dairy, but I believe he is still not satisfied with his job.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Let me start off by saying that I agree wholeheartedly that Angel's family is a cause of struggle in his life. That being said, another struggle that Angel faces is that of Tess's guilt. Because of this guilt, Tess repeatedly repulses Angel's numerous marriage proposals. This in turn, causes Angel to question himself, wondering if her refusal might be the result of a flaw he possesses. We, the reader, know that this not to be the case. Thankfully, Tess finally comes to terms with herself and accepts Angel's offer.

    ReplyDelete
  5. ECURTIS4
    One of Angel's biggest struggles is pleasing his family. He did not take on the family "business" but instead decided to do what he wanted and learn about farming. His family pushes on to him what they want. They want a good name in society and to do that thier children also must uphold teh expectations they have set. So now with Tess, Angel is again not pleasing his family. They want him to have a good wife, and now that Tess's secret is out, Angel does not believe that his parents will approve of her, even though he loves her. Angel faces high expectations, and that utimately he struggles with right now becasue of Tess.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Angel struggles with his own beliefs because he views life differently than his family but is still influenced by them. If his family was not as highly religious and judgmental, Angel might not have had a problem with Tess's past. Since his family did not approve of Tess in the first place her past makes his thoughts of whether he truely does love her more complex. He now has his reputation to think of because of his family instead of their love.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Angel feels the crushing pressure of social expectation on his proverbial shoulders. However, it is odd that the impetus of Tess seems to be the catalyst for any stress on the matter - son of a pastor, destined to follow, and yet somehow a rhetorist dairy farmer. Go figure that the one who is almost renowned for breaking away is so suddenly falling right in line with the spectrum of normal. For this reason, I must branch away from the simple explanation of a societal undertone (although there are moralities that are too deeply ingrained to be shrugged). It is possible that Angel is dealing with a crisis of misjudgment. The inadequacy of forgiveness between husband and wife for unequal crimes lends to this picture of Angel as more of a stuck up than perfect man. He is terrified that he was wrong about Tess' purity, and therefore angry about himself.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Angel is a very paradoxical character because in many ways he wishes to defy society’s expectations; however, when it comes to marriage he wants a pure wife. His whole life he has been working against his parents and not following their wishes. He has denied a formal education and becoming a pastor. His work at the dairy farm and various other establishments has helped him to realize that it is what he wants to do. This also gives him a chance to disobey his parents and follow his own interests unlike his older brothers. He struggles with disobeying his parents for these reasons. The whole time he is courting Tess and asking for her hand in marriage he never gives her the chance to tell him her secret. In a way, this is Angel’s fault so when he finds out her secret and can no longer love he has to struggle with him not letting her be honest. He does not have to struggle with forgiving her but he is not sure if he can love her again because he sees her as a completely different person. This news causes great turmoil in their relationship so he has to struggle with how to avoid the subject with his parents and what to do with his impure wife. This leads him to the idea of Brazil and although he makes the excuse that, he wants to learn a new form of farming he is really trying to escape all of the troubles he has with his family, Tess and himself.

    ReplyDelete
  9. I agree with Elissa when she says that Angel's main struggle revolves entirely around the approval of his family. Angel has always struggled with the fact that his parents can't accept his way of life. He doesn't want to disappoint them, but can never seem to do anything right in their eyes, between his choice of profession and his marriage to Tess. I feel that the reason Angel has such a difficult time accepting Tess after she confesses her impurity to him is because he convinced himself as well as his parents that she was a good and pure woman. When he finds out that he was wrong about her, it is just another way that Angel has let his family down. I feel that Angel probably would not have reacted the way he did if it weren't for his constant search for approval.

    ReplyDelete
  10. I disagree, I don't think Angel really is all that worried about the approval of his family. Yes, he wants them to be happy, but that is in the back of his mind. I think by the time he is at the farm working with Tess he has already overcome most of that struggle. I think that just because he is convincing his family of things, doesn't mean that he wasn't going to do them anyways. He is the definition of unconventional, he's had half the jobs trying to figure out what he wants to do, he's had a two day fling with another girl, he seems to hit on every single girl he comes across. Tess just got lucky that he picked her. I don't think he really struggles with loving her all that much. He decides it wouldn't be right to take another woman to Brazil with him, but yet barely hesitates to go back to Tess. I think his mind is made up. He says that if she had only told him sooner that things might have been different, but yet at the same time never gave her a chance. He isn't bothered by her love for him, for more than a mere few minutes. I think he struggles with himself more than anything. He idealizes, and sees everything through rose colored glasses. Then when things aren't as he thought he moves on. He is never happy with anything he has, or himself.

    ReplyDelete
  11. To me, Angel is not facing any real and valid issues in his life right now. Aside from what Janice said, he is really just being vain and selfish. Angel is being torn between is family and his true desires. ( As many of us applying to college now are too ) But his "issues" are all selfish. His biggest issue seems to be about Tess. If he could just get over himself and remember that he loves Tess, regaurdless of her impurity then all his issues would be resolved and he could lead a happy life. He is only considering other women and leaving for Brazil becasue he is unhappy with Tess over something that happened many years ago that she could not control. He only cares about himself and is very vain in thinking that he might deserve better than the woman who loves him the most simply becasue of a rape. Angel should obviously not be involved in the church if that is not what he wants to be involved in, and otehr than that, his only real problem is his evilness toward the situation with his wife.

    ReplyDelete
  12. I think Angel's largest struggle is dealing with the society of his time. He's an intellectual thinker, kind of a free spirit- those kind of people were probably few and far between during his time, or at least in the perimeter of the setting, as it is portrayed by the novel. His family is successful and wealthy, therefore they and many others expect him to follow his father and brothers into the stable career that they work in. He's a bit of a risk taker, and he's breaking out of the bounds of social class to work at the dairy farm and try agricultural life. His family doesn't approve, which of course is frustrating. And secondly, you can tell that he truly loves Tess by the way he treats her and the way she feels around him (in comparison to Alec). The second she tells him about the rape, though, a completely different side of him comes out. I think this side of him that dissapproves and causes him to reconsider his marriage with a woman he previously loved so much is created by society and the expectation that every woman should be pure, and that nothing bad should ever happen to her.

    B.FILARSKI

    ReplyDelete
  13. I agree with Bridget in saying that Angel's most difficult struggle is his battle against societal norms. Angel goes against society in his career path. At that time in history, a person listened to their parents and followed a very strict lifestyle and Angel has gone against his parents, exploring career options across the country. He also struggles against society's idea that women should be pure until marriage. Tess' impurity goes against the norm and Angel can no longer accept Tess. Although Angel has committed a similar act, because he is a male it is ok. In conclusion, Angel struggles with both sides of society's rules. He faces controversy both because he breaks the rules and because he obeys others.

    ReplyDelete
  14. I agree with both Bridget and Steve; I think that Angel's main struggle at the moment is his need for societal approval. It isnt so much that he is aching for his parents approval, but rather society as a whole. As he gets to know Tess and "fall in love" with her, he believes that though she is lower class, her purity will make up for that in society's eyes. So, in reality he was never in love with Tess but rather the idea of Tess' purity. As the reader, we know this to be true. This is pretty ironic though because even Angel doesnt realize these things about himself.

    ReplyDelete
  15. When Angel was born his father had already decided what he was going to grow up to be, and that was a parson. However, as Angel grew up he discovered that that was not for him. He wants to become a business man and go against the family plan. This is the same with Tess, his family wants him to have a good wife and Tess, in their eyes, is not that. He needs a plan in his life and right now he doesn't have that. This is why he leaves Tess and goes to Bazil, he is searching for a plan and he cannot find it.

    ReplyDelete
  16. When we are first introduced to Angel, he is characterized by his individuality compared to his family. He chose to go a different way than his family wanted him to do, and this marks one struggle he could be facing. Because he is doing what he wants instead of his family, he struggles with the kind of acceptance he wants from his parents. Along with this, after Angel meets Tess, he knows she is not the woman his parents have wanted him to marry. Even though he loves her so much he is again torn between what his family wants to do and what he wants to do. With Tess, when she tells him the truth about her past, Angel is now struggling against what he believes the right thing to do. He is hurt and confused, and though he loves Tess, the facts of her past cannot change. Ultimately Angel is facing a point in his life where he wants to get away from the struggles he has faced and is facing, but the major struggle is whether or not running away to Brazil will fix it.

    ReplyDelete
  17. I agree with Britney, at this point in the book(before phase five as this prompt was given before we read it) Angel's only real struggle seems to be what he wants to do with his life as far as an occupation and which one of the many girls that seem to love him he wants to make his bride. It is true that his family doesn't really approve of his decision to not go to a university and to pursue less prestigious careers but he seems to be pretty sure about what he’s doing. He'd like to have their support but he doesn't really struggle with it that much, and they even start to give him some of their support in Phase the Fourth. Also, it seems every girl that he comes in contact with becomes infatuated with him. He picks Tess who is in love with him and his biggest struggle turns out to be getting her to open up to him because she feels so guilty. Before phase five Angel really doesn’t seem to be having very many struggles. His life is being run the way he wants it too.

    ReplyDelete
  18. Angel is a generally good guy. He seems to have it all(speaking from before Phase the Fifth). All the young women love him, he has great potential to what he can achieve, and he is a very strong, independent thinker. His first real struggle that is revealed to the reader is that to get his parents approval of the girl he will marry. He falls for Tess, who his parents disapprove of because she is not from a noble family. However, this ends up being the least of his troubles with Tess. Gaining Tess trust is the biggest obstacle between Angel and Tess getting married. As we learn in Phase the Fifth however, Tess trusting Angel turns out to be a very bad thing.

    ReplyDelete
  19. At this point in his life Angel is struggling to recgonize for what it is and to realize reality as being something different from his philosophy books. Angel's fault with Tess occurs because of Angel's romantiscized view of the world. Angel is struggling to find a place where everything makes sense and works in the way he has always envisioned it working in his mind. This would explain his escape to Brazil, a foreign land, perhaps foreign enough to operate in the oppisite way as his native land, in the way he thinks it should.

    ReplyDelete
  20. Schen6
    I agree with many of the previous comments. I think Angel is having difficulties with his family as well as with his marriage. He wants to be a farmer, but his family expects certain things from him. He was being compared to his other brothers and therefore leading to his parents thinking that he should end up like them. With his marriage, he thinks that Tess betrayed him and so through this he feels like the person he loved doesn't exist anymore or never did . So I think the difficulties he's going through is primarily pressure from both his family and from Tess.

    ReplyDelete
  21. For one, Angel is against his parents because he wants to be with Tess, even though they are trying to persuade him otherwise. Another factor that he is fighting against is the milkmaids because he is protecting Tess from the allegations they are making against her past. The final group of people Angel is fighting against to protect Tess is society in general. He truely loves Tess and all the allegations the people within the town make against her forces him to protect her honor, even though they were right within their accusation. The main focus on Angel's struggles are to protect Tess and her honor, even though there is stuff he is unaware of Tess's past.

    ReplyDelete
  22. Angel is facing many issues in his life. He has faced many pressures from his family to be involved in the church. He struggles with feeling guilty about following his passions instead of what his family wishes for him to do. He also struggles with the guilt of having a past with another girl and still convict Tess for her past and leave her for it.

    ReplyDelete
  23. Angel is facing a large variety of problems in his life. One problem ANgel faces is not living up to his parents standards and wishes. His parents wished for him to be a minister, and to marry Mercy. He did not fulfill any of those wishes. Another problem that Angel faces is the impurity of his wife. Because he married a wife that was impure, he cannot accept that a live a happily married life.

    ReplyDelete
  24. Angel mainly deals with the pressures of his environment. He is faced with family and societal pressures, and he does not know what he truly wants. His tendencies leads him to rebel against most ideas and morals made popular by his family and society, and he is at his purest form when he is with Tess. Tess’ presence makes Angel feel comfort and himself, and after Tess breaks the news of her past to him, he instantly reacts how society would like him too. He is pressured by society’s standards, and he knows that despite his love for Tess he would be tormented if anyone found out about the news. The outside pressures he faces rule his life, as he cannot be the one he loves out of fear. His job, religion, and marriage all are against popular ideas of the time, and he willingly accepts this. But once a matter of extremer importance comes up he no longer goes against the grain, due to fear that he will no longer be accepted.

    Matt Deptola

    ReplyDelete